Lower member requirement for review

blang1 at 02h40

May

2009

I am not complaining about the refusal to review my forum, I am thinking of everyone here. I think that the requirement of 100 members for your site to be reviewed is too high. It should be lowered to at least 75. Alot of the forums submitted for review are growing, and a review would let them know what they need to do to make their forum better and attract more members.

Please consider this, all official reviewers!

1 Rok, on 12/05/2009 at 03h17

I think it should be 25 members needed to have your forum reviewed, not 75.

2 dragonintel, on 12/05/2009 at 03h22

great idea, somewhere between 25-50.6 would be nice.

3 Darren1, on 12/05/2009 at 03h46

I agree here, 100 members is way too much!

4 MrMario, on 12/05/2009 at 05h02

I'm too kind its lowered to 75 users with 200 messages.

5 Rok, on 12/05/2009 at 05h08

Thanks; but the messages wasn't a big deal. Almost every normal forum has about 500+ messages.

6 Walshy95, on 12/05/2009 at 22h02

I aggree that it should be lowered.

7 blang1, on 12/05/2009 at 22h28

It has been lowered to 75. Like someone said, messages isn't that big of a deal. My site has 96 members and 6258 messages.

8 ToxicKing, on 12/05/2009 at 22h49

they should be lowwered to 50 members or so.

9 Rok, on 12/05/2009 at 22h51

50 is too low. If a forum has to have 50 members, then what would be the point of reviewing the forum with such a low amount of members (no offense to the users who do have less than 50 members.)
I was immature to say 25 members. Very Happy

10 clubpenguinforums, on 13/05/2009 at 21h47

Maybe another section for forums in the making would be helpful (like a subsection thing)

11 MrMario, on 13/05/2009 at 23h12

Read below

Hello Forumotion users,

The Review Team has place some way of requesting reviews for your forum and the requirements for picking them.

=>Full Review- You will need 75 members with 200 messages
=>Choose up to two differnet areas 30 users with 200 messages
=>Choose up to three area's 45 users with 200 messages

=>All forum have to be Enlgish and if they aren't the topic will be locked.

Have any questions please ask them in the Only Topic
Thanks

-Forumotion Review Team

So don't know why you are saying it needs lowered

12 Xiso, on 14/05/2009 at 00h07

MrMario wrote:Read below

Hello Forumotion users,

The Review Team has place some way of requesting reviews for your forum and the requirements for picking them.

=>Full Review- You will need 75 members with 200 messages
=>Choose up to two differnet areas 30 users with 200 messages
=>Choose up to three area's 45 users with 200 messages

=>All forum have to be Enlgish and if they aren't the topic will be locked.

Have any questions please ask them in the Only Topic
Thanks

-Forumotion Review Team

So don't know why you are saying it needs lowered

If not english, I could most likely help out!

13 Splytte, on 15/05/2009 at 01h14

The aim of a review is to help improve people with their forums, so why do you just review forums with already a big success?

-=~Splytte~=-

14 Fireflare88, on 24/05/2009 at 23h54

Can the member requirement be lowered with a substantial number of posts?

15 MrMario, on 25/05/2009 at 02h07

200 is not that hard to get and its easy to get if your forum have 10-15 members. You have 1841 messages so I don't see whats the problem. Also you have to remove your topic icaons as they are copyright to the support forum ONLY.

16 :)tayne:), on 25/05/2009 at 17h48

I agree with this =>Voted yes.

17 MrMario, on 27/05/2009 at 07h16

Already done