C.P. Forum Croatia for Veljko

Cb Hr at 12h26

May

2009

Name of the Forum: Club Penguin Forum Hrvatska
Address: http://clubpenguin.forum3.info/
Suggestions?: design, members...
Other:
What categories would you like the reviewer to review? All=>Full Review

1 MrMario, on 16/05/2009 at 00h24

Random what?

2 Xiso, on 16/05/2009 at 00h50

Just choose any sections, I believe he meant.

This is most likely a partial review!

3 Cb Hr, on 16/05/2009 at 12h45

yes, any section, but I wait Monday and Veljko

4 Veljko, on 17/05/2009 at 23h21

Review

Forum Style:

Graphics: Really nice navigation bar. I love it because it is different than other navigation bars. I do like images you use for new, old, and locked forums. I think that you should have made your topic icons for new, old, locked, stickies and announcements smaller. Those are really big for forum. (Score: 9/10)

Banner: I like the colors. It is good but I do not like the font you used for text "Hrvatska", It looks as not clear as other text. I suggest changing the font.(Score: 8/10)

Colors: All is well configured. Nice style and colors for forum's theme. (Score: 15/15)

Total: 32/35

Forum Index:

Organization: The forum have the right sections in each Categories and is easy to find what you are looking for. (Score: 10/10)

Categories & Forums: Nice, but I do not like the packing of index you used. (Score: 14/15)

Index & Portal Appearance: Widgets do what they have to do. All the info is there! (Score: 10/10)

Total: 34/35

Staff:

Staff Population: Three staff members is nice. If I were you i would just add one more moderator to keep the balance.
(Score: 5/5)

Staff Activity & Moderation: They seem to know when they should go online and how long. As I can see, there are no off topic messages or spam on forum which keeps it clean and nice. Good job! (Score: 5/5)

Staff Groups: Three groups. admins, mods and super mods, nice. As already stated i would add one more mod that deserves the position.(Score: 4/5)

Total 14/15

Members

Forum Date & Activity: You have nice amount of members but low count of post for that number. Newsltter is a nice thing that I would use If I were you. Nice way to notify members they are members on your forum. (Score: 4/5)

Daily Posts & Threads: The posts number is well balanced. Although there are more topics in off topic section.(Score: 4/5)

Member Population: Nice amount of more than 445 members. Keep it up. (Score: 5/5)

Total 13/15

Total Score: 93/100
Grade: A-

5 MrMario, on 19/05/2009 at 18h47

=> Moved to Review Archives