Tagged

I will do this starting tomorrow.

Thank you MrMario

Missing Madelene Review

Graphics:

Nav Buttons: I don't care about the Register Button flashing it is jumpy and could need some work, I would also make them more readable since some people can have problems reading that kind of stuff. (Score: 8/10)

Banner: I don't know but to me I would make the wording on the banner make it stand out more since it says what the forum is. Banner is simple and is looking good. (Score: 10/10)

Colors: Colors fit very well and they won't need any changing. (Score: 10/10)

Total: 28/30

Display/Layout:

Organization: You have the welcome section 2nd? That should be first so that the members can find it easy and can see it if there is any new stuff that they need to know. Games should be at the bottom of your main idea of the forum so that members aren't always doing that. (Score: 7/10)

Categories & Forums: They all seem to have a great number of post for a lot of forums for the members. I wouldn't add anymore till the forum is more active and if its needed. (Score: 10/10)

Index & Portal Appearance: Its a little to plan for the forum and it really needs some graphics and or widgets to move around the forum better. (Score: 8/10)

Total: 25/30

General:

Staff Population: looks like you have a nice size of staff. Can't really see the full list or the groups (Score: 4/5)

Staff Activity & Moderation: Staff is active from the time frame that I am on and shows that your members do care about the forum and want to make sure that the forum is safe for the others. (Score: 5/5)

Staff Groups: I can't tell if you have a graphic person but if you don't I would recommend you put it hidden till you get someone so that members don't ask when you are going to get someone to do the job. (Score: 4/5)


Total 13/15


Members:

Forum Date & Activity: Forum look active and they do seem to like the forum and how it runs. Great job.
(Score: 5/5)

Daily Posts & Threads: Have a lot of messages on your forum for 137 members. This is very good for showing the guest that the forum is active and hopefully will make them register and get involved. (Score: 5/5)

Member Population: Not many users on your forum for 137 members. try sending out New Letter some time in the month talking about the news updates and get members involved. (Score: 3/5)


Total 13/15

Total Score: 79/90
Grade: 87% B+

Thank you for the review MrMario. Its better than I expected to be honest but I will certainly take your advice and make some changes....

I have *164* members but I clean them up regularly as I dont like lurkers who register and have 0 comments so after a week I remove them...

And yes I do have a designer...he's on the legend...

Once again many thanks for the review x

Thanks for requesting a review, Amersuz. If you want, you can rate your review.

Complete
Nice review Mario.