Lords of Sea and Sky MH3 clan Forum Review

Abhi09 at 18h18
16
Apr
2011
Name of the Forum: Lo(t)SaS (Lords of (the) Sea and Sky)
Address: http://losas.forumotion.com/forum
Area's you wish the reviewer to review: Two Area's Review: General, Design/Theme & Lay out
Your Name on the board: Abhi admin password removed

It's a mh3 clan thing so it may not have many users... Thanks in advance :wouhou: bounce
1 Base, on 16/04/2011 at 18h24
Never post your admin password in a public place such as a forum! I have removed it for your safety to avoid being hacked.
2 Abhi09, on 16/04/2011 at 20h44
oh sorry... didn't realize that you could see that...
3 slamsol, on 17/04/2011 at 00h07
Review Content Removed~ Rideem3
Due to copyrighted template
4 Jophy, on 17/04/2011 at 07h08
slamsol wrote:
Unofficial forum review
General- The widgets and things are cool and so is the layout. It has nice color's and images.
Theme/Layout- To be honest the background does not suit the color's it is a bit hard to read at times and does not really match the forum much
Rating- 7/10 you might earn a 9 if you change the background image




This was a review by slamsol. Currently is a unofficial review.
Catch my forums here amazing source of Runescape things.
I am not a official reviewer yet so this was not a official review just my review.



The review gave less info :/
Are you satisfied with the review? If not, you can let others take this request.
5 slamsol, on 17/04/2011 at 12h05
I made you a new one because joph25 said he did not like it.


Review Content removed
6 Jophy, on 17/04/2011 at 12h08
I didn't say that I didn't liked it, it's just too less to be called a review :/

And he's not requesting a full review, he's just requesting a 2 area review so I removed your review. Thanks for your effort anyway.
7 slamsol, on 17/04/2011 at 12h45
Joph25 wrote:I didn't say that I didn't liked it, it's just too less to be called a review :/

And he's not requesting a full review, he's just requesting a 2 area review so I removed your review. Thanks for your effort anyway.


Ok I just took a template.

Thanks anyway.

Edit: Hey joph25 you review don't you? Can you review my forum please?
8 Jophy, on 17/04/2011 at 13h22
slamsol wrote:
Joph25 wrote:I didn't say that I didn't liked it, it's just too less to be called a review :/

And he's not requesting a full review, he's just requesting a 2 area review so I removed your review. Thanks for your effort anyway.


Ok I just took a template.

Thanks anyway.

Edit: Hey joph25 you review don't you? Can you review my forum please?

I don't have the time for now, please stop replying to this thread now, such discussions can be brought on PM. Thanks.
9 Drogba921, on 17/04/2011 at 15h50
Didnt know if you wanted this reviewing, but I did it anyway..

Forum Name Here



Congratulations! Your forum review has been completed. The forum review will hold many tips, suggestions, comments, and feedback that are convenient and voluntary for your forum. Here is your forum review:





Rating - Poor


First thing is first, Too many color the colors don't blend together and they are either too bright or too dull. Your forum has no specific set theme to it, it is just a bunch of images placed in places in what looks like hope that it will look good. You really have nothing set out, except your forums which to be honest are in a rather big jumble across the forum.. I cannot read half of the text across the page of the forum, and the text is too dark of a color. You can set some custom background colors in your Customized CSS in your administration panel at any time, or even set a theme without losing any of your forums. I hate to sound really mean at the first part of a review, but it is my humble opinion, and lots of things on this forum need to be fixed, if it is going to be successful. You also have no background to your posts...








Rating - Very Poor


Banner: If I were to pick two words that come to mind when I saw a banner like yours, they would be Obtrusive and Hard to read. You banner should fit in the Blackish Gray gradiented space at the top of your forum and not drop below it... And it would be ideal if your banner was transparent so it wouldnt be green colors clashing with black ones on your forum. Your image is also saved as a Jpeg, save it as a PNG and it might be slightly easier to read depending on what you did to your banner before you saved it.

Forum Images: Your category images are probably the only ones on the forum that make actual sense to use, becuse they fit well. The ones inside your forum have a dark background and still look really bad on your forums layout, mainly because there is no set background for the theme, if you had one it might actually look better. There are some things that are really critical to your forum and I'd say It's lacking images to be honest, or they're random.

Background: Your background is my biggest objection to your forum, it's too dark and uses too many shades of gray, so almost every color you pick will be too dark, too light, or just won't look good at all because of the background. You actually need to set a background for your posts and also your sidebar content on your forum, because it's lacking one... Your current background just looks terrible and I think this is why it deserves the very poor rank.

Backgrounds to your forum categories on rollover are terrible too. I was reviewing this forum in my room without any lights, and when I hovered over something it was like a camera flashed in my eyes... It was too bright. If you're going to use gray for your actual category colors, use a lighter gray (not white) on your rollover and it might look better than what it is right now.

Other: I urge you to get a theme from Hitskin. Your forum will look much better with it and it will not look as bad as it does now. A hitskin theme is precoded so all you have to do is import it and then your forum will stay the same, it will just move your current information of your forum into the premade cateogry section of your forum.


I hate to sound mean when reviewing this forum but it honestly does need alot alot of work. See if you can get your fantastic five to help you out when redoing the forum!



DISCLAIMER: I am here to help you improve your forum, we give suggestions based upon what we see on your forum. This is just advice and it is not required to take action. Please do not lash out at me because I did not give your forum a good score. You're the one who requests a review, and we are simply giving feedback. Thank you.
10 Rideem3, on 18/04/2011 at 02h08
Your review has been proofread and has been marked "completed." This review has been accepted and will now be moved to the official review archives. Wink
If there were any mistakes that I found to be a misunderstanding, I edited it out, and made the correct additions to the review in bold color.
Similar topics
Name of the Forum: Foundations of Destruction Clan Address: www.fodclan.com Area's you wish the reviewer to review: full review Thanks so much
Name of the Forum: Naga Lords Address: http://nagalords.forumotion.net/forum.htm What categories would you like the reviewer to review? Graphics
Name of the Forum: Ultramaps forums Address: Edited out-thanks for the review! Area's you wish the reviewer to review: Display Your Name on the board: Alex
See also
more_less
Informations

10 Replies For the topic :
"Lords of Sea and Sky MH3 clan Forum Review"

This topic has been viewed 1098 times.

Last message :
16/04/2011 at 18h18 by "Abhi09"